Summary
Old slopsmith docs (TODO.md, docs/NOTE_FAILURE_SPEC.md, NOTE_FAILURE_PLAN.md) describe a planned "note failure feedback" system — Riff-Repeater-style miss diagnosis that classifies a miss as too-late, too-early, too-sharp, or too-flat rather than just hit/miss. Grepping both the old and current trees for the relevant terms (too_late, too_early, too_sharp, too_flat, miss_reason, failure_reason) turns up nothing — this was a documented plan, not a feature that ever shipped in either slopsmith or feedBack.
Ask
This is a genuine gap relative to the old project's stated intent, but unlike the other issues filed alongside this one it's not a regression — nothing to restore, just a design to pick up if there's still interest. Worth a maintainer read of the old spec docs to decide whether it's still wanted before scoping real work.
Context
Found via a comparison audit of old slopsmith/slopsmith-plugin-* vs current feedBack/feedBack-plugin-*, done to identify features lost when Slopsmith was scrapped (DMCA/PSARC) and rewritten as feedBack. Verified not a duplicate of any open issue (searched "note failure", "riff repeater", "miss diagnosis").
Summary
Old slopsmith docs (
TODO.md,docs/NOTE_FAILURE_SPEC.md,NOTE_FAILURE_PLAN.md) describe a planned "note failure feedback" system — Riff-Repeater-style miss diagnosis that classifies a miss as too-late, too-early, too-sharp, or too-flat rather than just hit/miss. Grepping both the old and current trees for the relevant terms (too_late,too_early,too_sharp,too_flat,miss_reason,failure_reason) turns up nothing — this was a documented plan, not a feature that ever shipped in either slopsmith or feedBack.Ask
This is a genuine gap relative to the old project's stated intent, but unlike the other issues filed alongside this one it's not a regression — nothing to restore, just a design to pick up if there's still interest. Worth a maintainer read of the old spec docs to decide whether it's still wanted before scoping real work.
Context
Found via a comparison audit of old
slopsmith/slopsmith-plugin-*vs currentfeedBack/feedBack-plugin-*, done to identify features lost when Slopsmith was scrapped (DMCA/PSARC) and rewritten as feedBack. Verified not a duplicate of any open issue (searched "note failure", "riff repeater", "miss diagnosis").