Skip to content

Add the R1 novelty check and scoping decision - #745

Draft
LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
retrieval/p552-r1-novelty-20260913
Draft

LightChainr wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
retrieval/p552-r1-novelty-20260913

Conversation

@LightChainr

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

R1 (15-state ordered serial algebra): novelty check + scoping decision

Novelty-only retrieval note + a decision memo (the ticket asks for the memo before any prose).
No manuscript draft is written.

Asset-list freshness

Every PR cited in the ticket (#511#519, #493, #495, #387, #448, #330) is MERGED → the
merged-asset list is current. Caveat: docs/PUBLICATION-PORTFOLIO.md (the R1 rating source) is
not on main — it lives only on the still-OPEN PR #548, so the R1 "gate" is proposed, not yet
repo policy.

Novelty retrieval (cite-or-gap)

  • Serial / Nakayama algebras: classified by quivers (linear Aₙ or cyclic) + relations — infinite
    family over a field, not a 15-element transformation semigroup. [LIT]
  • Diagram / partition monoids: infinite families in n; idempotent-generated sectors studied, no
    15-element match. ABSTRACT_ONLY
  • SmallSemi GAP census: exhaustive only to order 8 → cannot confirm/deny novelty at order 15. [LIT]
  • Exact phrase "15-state ordered serial algebra": no hit. WebSearch

Conclusion: GAP (with residual-verification caveat). No prior classification of this exact
object under another name was found, but novelty is not yet positively certified — the object's
full multiplication table was not retrieved, and order-15 confirmation needs a SmallSemi-style
enumeration or a multiplication-table/Green-relations match (not done here).

Decision memo

Pursue Option B (pure finite-semigroup publication) as the fast path, in parallel with Option A.
No prior match ⇒ Option B is a plausible standalone paper pending the order-15 verification. Option A
(probability connection / obstruction theorem) stays open and is the higher-impact path; the
portfolio doc lists task 4 (= Option B comparison) as a legitimate high-value task, so the two are
not exclusive. Residual verification (GAP SmallSemi at order 15, or table match) is a pre-submission
requirement, not a blocker for drafting.

Full Matching-One repository CI has not been run for this commit.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant